The regarding the pain of others community note includes chapterbychapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and. Defining torture and cruel, inhuman, and degrading treatment. Convention against torture and other cruel, inhuman or. Aug 02, 2003 regarding the pain of others by susan sontag hamish hamilton. Start your 48hour free trial to unlock this regarding the pain of others study guide and get instant access to the following summary. Feb 20, 2015 a quick summary of regarding the torture of others by susan sontag which was included in cupcakes and kalashnikovs. Torture and abusive interrogation tactics are illegal under both u. For a long time at least six decades photographs have laid. In regarding the pain of others, susan sontag examines the manner in which war is perceived, taking into account such factors as sex, culture and status. Human rights watch s 2011 report getting away with torture details the numerous times us courts found that waterboarding, or variations of it, constitutes torture and is a war crime. Torture and the united states includes documented and alleged cases of torture both inside and outside the united states by members of the government, the military, law enforcement agencies, intelligence agencies, health care services, and other public organizations. Declaring a war against terror, the united states has detained foreign nationals suspected of terrorist activities and has interrogated them at various locations outside the united states. Regarding the torture of others the new york times. Background regarding the issue to be addressed according to the united nations convention against torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment 1984.
In her text, regarding the pain of others 2003, susan sontag. Regarding the pain of others 2003 was susan sontags last published book before her death in 2004. Jul 15, 2017 regarding the torture of others article in ny times by susan sontag, may 23 2004 link 7 this article refers to the photographs taken in abu ghraib prison in iraq originally sadam husseins most infamous prison. In fact, most of the torture photographs have a sexual theme, as in those showing the coercing of prisoners to perform, or simulate, sexual acts. This brief collection shows that abu ghraib is not only consistent with u. Susan sontags new book, regarding the pain of others, updates, expands, and in certain respects repudiates her 1977 book on photography. But those certainly are dead children, and that undoubtedly is the section of a house. Mar 11, 2003 torture and condoned its use by others as part of its war against terrorism.
In regarding the pain of others, sontag considers the subject of atrocity photography. Where on photography was quite theoretical and full of jargon, following, as it did, the work of the french critic roland barthes, regarding the pain of others is a series of simple ideas written in plain language. Again, slightlyyyyy longer than one minute but it was a really interesting. Torture, american style places those crimes in historical context, undermining the claims of president bush and many others that what transpired at abu ghraib was an aberration. This study guide consists of approximately 21 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of regarding the pain of others. Oct 17, 2012 a summary of regarding the torture of others by. Torture, american style historians against the war. Vernon foley 2012 the author, susan sontag, uses this tragic record of events to explore the power of imagery to tell a story that words cannot bring to light. February 7, 2002 memo regarding the applicability of the geneva conventions to alqaeda and. It was her last published book before her death in 2004. Regarding the pain of others, by susan sontag garage. Regarding the pain of others is a meditative analysis of the iconography of suffering. Pdf regarding the pain of others book by susan sontag free.
Regarding the torture of others by susan sontag susan sontag born january 16, 1933 december 28, 2004 was an american writer, filmmaker, teacher, and political activist. Regarding the torture of others article in ny times by susan sontag, may 23 2004 link 7 this article refers to the photographs taken in abu ghraib prison in iraq originally sadam husseins most infamous prison. The torture convention was the result of many years work, initiated soon after the adoption of the declaration on the protection of all persons from being subjected to torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment the torture declaration by the general assembly on 9 december 1975 resolution 3452 xxx. The first edition of the novel was published in january 7th 2001, and was written by susan sontag. Regarding the torture of others susan sontag new york.
Others are so little able to suffer that they prefer to lie rather than to endure the question, and hence it happens that they make confessions of different kinds, and they not only implicate themselves, but others as well. The legal prohibition against torture human rights watch. Resolution regarding extended solitary confinement and. Susan sontag essay offers her reflections on torture of iraqi prisoners by americans at abu ghraib, and the photographs that have appeared of. Jan 07, 2003 in regarding the pain of others, sontag considers the subject of atrocity photography. But if tortured, slaves were considered to have sufficient reason to tell the truthto end thetorture. A summary of regarding the torture of others seize the future. She spent in sarajevo much of the time between early 1993 and 1996 and was made an. On his second day in office, president obama issued an executive order strengthening the ban on torture and limiting.
It is a followup to her classic collection of essays on photography, published 26 years earlier and recently released in russian as part of the garage publishing program in collaboration with ad marginem press. This pdf may not be placed on any website or other. This 33page guide for regarding the pain of others by susan sontag includes detailed chapter summaries and analysis covering 9 chapters, as well as several more indepth sections of expertwritten literary analysis. Mar 15, 2003 with a glance back at the essays in on photography 1977, the eminent intellectual, critic, and writer cobbles together a defense of war photographywith a result thats as much maunder as miracle.
Regarding the torture of others susan sontag new york times magazine. Torture has been a tool of coercion for nearly all of human history, whether to instill fear in a population or force people to convert, but almost all contemporary attempts to justify the use of torture revolve around torture as a means of extracting information from a victim. Sontags statements about photographs of suffering might also help us think about the function of writing and reading about others suffering. Regarding the torture of others colin caygill digital image. Vernon foley 2012 the author, susan sontag, uses this tragic record of events to explore the power. Aug 21, 2018 8212018 regarding the torture of others the new york times 211 took place in abu ghraib and what has taken place elsewhere in iraq and in afghanistan and at guantanamo bay by its true name, torture, is as outrageous as the refusal to call the rwandan genocide a genocide. With a glance back at the essays in on photography 1977, the eminent intellectual, critic, and writer cobbles together a defense of war photographywith a. Seeing images of far away atrocities, sontag asserts, is a quintessentially modern experience.
General franco was using the same tactics of bombardment, massacre, torture, and the killing and mutilation of prisoners that he had perfected as a commanding officer in morocco in the 1920s. Thus the greek legal orator demosthenes, among others, could argue. This mornings collection contains the photograph of what might be a mans body, or a womans. Declaring a war against terror, the united states has detained foreign nationals suspected of terrorist activities and has interrogated them at various locations outside the. This prezi is a visual companion to susan sontags essay, regarding the pain of others.
Wright wrt 105 6 september 2009 regarding the torture of others summary regarding the torture of others, a powerful piece written by susan sontag, focuses on the horrific pictures taken by american soldiers in the abu ghraib prison. To probe reciprocity and public opinion toward torture, a unique question order experiment from a 1,000 person subsample of the 2006 cooperative congressional election study cces is utilized. Sontag, regarding the torture of others the new york times. Protests have been held regarding the issue of torture and its legality as lately. For a long time at least six decades photographs have laid down the tracks of how important conflicts.
Slaves were expected to lie if questioned openly, particularly if they feared punishment from their master. Torture is prohibited under federal law, as are lesser forms of detainee abuse such as cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment. Regarding the pain of others is a 2003 booklength essay by susan sontag, which was nominated for the national book critics circle award. Regarding the torture of others summary remy lundy mrs. The regarding the pain of others community note includes chapterbychapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and quizzes written by community members like you. This is susan sontags second book on photography and, like the first, published in. Regarding the torture of others for a long time at least six decades photographs have laid down the tracks of how important conflicts are judged and remembered.
The behavior in the pictures is the very nature of the. Torture and the ethics of photographya semantic scholar. Including action, sports, girls, puzzle, multiplayer and free games. Regarding the torture of others susan sontag summary. Office of legal counsel olc regarding the interrogation of detainees. Susan sontag regarding the pain of others by a lau on prezi.
A and others v secretary of state for the home department 2004 ukhl 56 hc 510094 public committee against torture in israel v. Regarding the pain of others in susan sontag and alfredo jaar. Free download or read online regarding the pain of others pdf epub book. Torture and the united states includes documented and alleged cases of torture both inside. Regarding the pain of others susan sontag monoskop.
The western memory museum is now mostly a visual one. The photographs are us, but they are everyone else, too. Regarding the pain of others quotes by susan sontag. Then, more acceptably to ruling powers, his victims had been spains colonial subjects, darkerhued and infidels to boot. Dec 12, 2016 regarding the torture of others by susan sontag susan sontag born january 16, 1933 december 28, 2004 was an american writer, filmmaker, teacher, and political activist. She takes a strong position on defending the prisoners and uses powerful words to back her. She contends that war imagery is open to both interpretation and manipulation. She spent in sarajevo much of the time between early 1993 and 1996 and was made an honorary citizen of the city. Report of the committee against torture, thirtysixth session pdf. The book was published in multiple languages including english, consists of 117 pages and is available in paperback format. Supersummary, a modern alternative to sparknotes and cliffsnotes, offers highquality study guides for challenging works of literature.
Regarding the pain of others the new york times magazine. Regarding the torture of others susan sontag new york times. Dec 09, 2014 human rights watch s 2011 report getting away with torture details the numerous times us courts found that waterboarding, or variations of it, constitutes torture and is a war crime. Sontag rejects the notion that war imagery will necessarily compel. A quick summary of regarding the torture of others by susan sontag which was included in cupcakes and kalashnikovs.
It is regarded by many to be a followup or addendum to on photography, despite the fact that the two essay collections convey sontags radically. When she says, no we should be taken for granted when the subject is looking at other peoples pain, i thought of how differently a patients suffering might be written about by a doctor, a nurse, a. The author, susan sontag, uses this tragic record of events to explore the power of imagery to tell a story that words cannot bring to light. This is susan sontags second book on photography and, like the first, published in 1977, it contains no photographs. Regarding the pain of others photographs we feel the same things. The main characters of this non fiction, philosophy story are. In her text, regarding the pain of others 2003, susan sontag torture and the ethics of photographya judith butler rhetoric department, 7408 dwinelle hall, university of california, berkeley, ca 94720, usa.